Compliance review follow-up report: Gambling Survey for Great Britain

Published:

Findings

Recommendation one

To improve user confidence in the GSGB, the Gambling Commission should develop a more detailed and comprehensive improvement plan to communicate how Professor Sturgis’ recommendations will be actioned.

Actions taken by the Gambling Commission

The Gambling Commission has published an ‘Implementing the recommendations from Professor Sturgis’ page to provide updates on the actions it has taken to address Professor Sturgis’ recommendations, as well as links to further research. Following feedback from OSR, in July 2026 the Gambling Commission updated this page to provide more complete and timely information. For example, the page now includes the most up-to-date information on the Gambling Commission’s work to investigate Professor Sturgis’ recommendation that ‘the Gambling Commission should seek opportunities to benchmark the estimates from the GSGB against a contemporaneous face-to-face interview survey in the future’. The Gambling Commission also provides a link to the comparative research reported by Professor Heather Wardle examining comparability between the GSGB and data from the Health Survey for England.

The Gambling Commission has published a ‘Continuous Improvement’ page, which is linked from the GSGB landing page. The Continuous Improvement page provides a link to the ‘Implementing the recommendations from Professor Sturgis’ page as well as information about OSR’s compliance review and the action that the Gambling Commission has taken as a result of this work.

OSR judgement

We consider this recommendation to be met.

Following the July 2026 update, the ‘Implementing the recommendations from Professor Sturgis’ page is now more comprehensive and up to date. It includes the work done to address the recommendations as well as the action that the Gambling Commission has taken as a result of this work. The ‘Continuous Improvement’ page is also helpful for users. It brings together information on OSR’s compliance review and the Gambling Commission’s subsequent actions, as well as actions to address Professor Sturgis’ recommendations. To further improve how it communicates its action to address Professor Sturgis’ recommendations, the Gambling Commission should commit to regular, comprehensive updates in future. This will ensure that the information continues to be updated and valuable to users.


Recommendation two

To assure users and enhance confidence in the GSGB data, the Gambling Commission should provide more detailed information on its quality assurance and validation processes.

Actions taken by the Gambling Commission

The Gambling Commission has provided more information on quality assurance and how GSGB data are validated within the technical report. There is now comprehensive information about the Commission’s work with the Bingo Association and GamStop to explore why there are differences between GSGB estimates and industry administrative data. The technical report also links to relevant information about validation, such as a report that summarises the outcomes from the Bingo Association work. Within the technical report, the Gambling Commission now links to further information about its quality assurance processes, for example, its ‘quality management approach for statistics’ page.

OSR judgement

We consider this recommendation to be met.

The Gambling Commission has provided more detail about its validation work and made it easier for users to navigate its information about quality assurance, which will support user confidence in the Gambling Commission’s processes.


Recommendation three

To support appropriate interpretation and use of the GSGB data, the Gambling Commission should:

  • clearly communicate to users within the statistical releases the potential biases that may affect the GSGB estimates, the possible impact of these, and Professor Sturgis’ conclusion regarding the risk that the statistics potentially overestimate some gambling behaviours
  • explain what the statistics can and cannot be used for, and why
  • ensure that guidance on how to use the statistics is easy to find and tailored to different users, such as the media.

Actions taken by the Gambling Commission

1. Clearly communicate potential biases and the possible impact of these within the statistical release

Sturgis et al’s 2025 research

The GSGB estimates of gambling prevalence and harm are higher than those from face-to-face interview surveys such as the Health Survey for England (HSE) and the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey (APMS). In 2025, the Gambling Commission commissioned Sturgis, Kuha, Howe and Maxineanu to carry out research to improve understanding of the underlying causes of these differences. This study, ‘Three experiments on the causes of differences in estimates of gambling and gambling impacts in general population surveys’, was also undertaken to address some of the recommendations that Professor Sturgis made in his 2024 report ‘Assessment of the Gambling Survey for Great Britain’. Within that report, Professor Sturgis recommended that the Gambling Commission conduct further research on the impact of the Gambling Commission’s methodology on estimates of gambling prevalence and harm.

Sturgis et al (2025) concluded that ‘the results of these experiments suggest that a large part of the variation in estimates of gambling and gambling impacts between face-to-face interview and online self-completion surveys is due to differences in sample composition resulting from the subject of the invitation and higher levels of socially desirable responding due to interviewer presence’. The authors made the following recommendations to the Gambling Commission based on this research:

  1. Update guidance on how GSGB results should be interpreted to better reflect the likely causes of the differences between it and earlier estimates produced by the health surveys.
  2. Conduct further benchmarking against the 2023/24 Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey (APMS) to better understand remaining differences between surveys.

This research was a valuable opportunity to gain further understanding of the underlying causes of the differences between self-completion surveys (such as the GSGB) and interviewer-led surveys (such as the HSE).

The Gambling Commission has been transparent about the research that Sturgis et al (2025) conducted. The research has been published in full and is linked from several locations on the Gambling Commission website. The Gambling Commission has also hosted two webinars alongside Professor Sturgis about the research. The first webinar outlined the purpose and aims of the research and the second explained the findings to users. The Gambling Commission also published a news story alongside the completion of this research. However, the Gambling Commission can do more to explain, in its own words, these findings in the context of the GSGB, exactly how these findings have influenced its confidence in the GSGB, and its subsequent decision making. These areas for further improvement are discussed in the following sections.

The risk of overestimation in the GSGB

The GSGB is a push-to-web mixed-mode self-completion survey, with both online and paper questionnaires. Invitation letters are sent to prospective participants who are directed to the online questionnaire. For ethical reasons, this invitation informs participants that the study is about gambling.

Sturgis et al’s research (2025) found that the presence of an interviewer had a substantial effect on reported gambling impacts and that this strongly suggests that respondents under-report undesirable behaviours in the presence of an interviewer. In our view, given the GSGB’s online self-completion element, this suggests that the GSGB’s risk of overestimation for problem gambling estimates is not as high as previously thought.

It should be noted that Sturgis et al’s (2025) research found that the difference in Problem Gambling Severity Index scores between the control and treatment groups (i.e. the group that received a survey invitation that mentioned gambling and the group whose invitation did not) was not statistically significant. However, Sturgis et al noted that the power to detect an effect of this size with this sample size is low and that ‘it would be reasonable to expect a larger effect for a standalone push-to-web survey like the GSGB, where respondents are likely to spend more time reading the more extensive survey materials before deciding whether or not to take part.’

Sturgis et al (2025) also found that while mentioning gambling explicitly in the survey invitation did not affect the overall response rate, it did lead to a 4-percentage point increase in reported gambling participation. Therefore, in our view, the research indicates there is still a risk of overestimation of gambling participation estimates. Whilst it is unknown how this finding affects the accuracy of the survey, bias does exist. There is uncertainty, as would be expected for any statistical estimates, and this uncertainty and potential bias needs to be prominently explained to users within the statistical release.

The Gambling Commission’s communication of biases

Within the technical report, the Gambling Commission outlines the GSGB’s strengths and limitations. As noted in our previous review, the technical report is clear in communicating that the GSGB statistics are estimates and are subject to a margin of error. Specific strengths and limitations are listed, and there is discussion of Sturgis et al’s (2025) research findings regarding the potential for the GSGB to disproportionately attract those who gamble. In the technical report, the Gambling Commission concludes that there is a risk of overestimation and states that ‘it should be kept in mind that the survey overestimates the true level of gambling in the population’.

Following conversations with OSR regarding communicating biases within the statistical release, the Gambling Commission included some additional text within the GSGB Annual Report 2025 published in July 2026. Within the ‘Interpretation of the data’ section, the Gambling Commission states that:

‘In line with general literature on survey methodology, and the findings from Sturgis (2025) (opens in new tab) we know that a gambling focused survey like GSGB can over sample people who gamble, but the presence of an interviewer (as per previous survey methodologies) has a substantial effect on reported gambling impacts. Therefore, comparisons with surveys prior to year 1 of the GSGB (2023) should not be made’.

Areas for improvement in the Gambling Commission’s communication of biases

Our compliance review found that whilst there is comprehensive information to support the use and interpretation of GSGB statistics within the technical report and the guidance, this is not included within the statistical release. The ‘Be open about quality’ standard of the Code requires producers to prominently explain the quality of the statistics, their strengths and limitations, and communicate their uncertainty. Therefore, a fundamental element of recommendation three was that the Gambling Commission should communicate potential biases within the statistical release itself.

In January 2026, in its updated response to our compliance review, the Gambling Commission stated that the research by Sturgis et al (2025) ‘found that the risk of overestimation in the GSGB was not as high as initially thought’. It did not, therefore, add additional warnings to the GSGB statistical release about the risk of overestimation in line with our recommendation. However, the risk of overestimation is explicitly referred to within the GSGB technical report. In our view, the potential risk of overestimation is essential information that all users should be aware of. This information should be made more prominent within the statistical release, as we originally recommended. Users who only look at the statistical release and not the technical report will not be aware of this important information.

The new information included in the GSGB Annual Report 2025 alludes to potential biases, but it does not adequately explain them and does not help users understand the implications of these biases for the estimates themselves. The ambiguity of this information is potentially confusing for users. For example, it does not mention the implications of this potential oversampling, it assumes that the reader understands the survey mode, it does not clarify what is meant by a ‘substantial effect’ on reported gambling habits, and it does not explain what is meant by ‘surveys prior to year 1’. The limitations of a gambling-focused survey are presented as a possibility (‘a gambling-focused survey like GSGB can oversample’) but the limitations of an interviewer-administered survey are presented as fact (‘the presence of an interviewer (as per previous survey methodologies) has a substantial effect on reported gambling impacts’). The phrasing also implies that the potential oversampling is offset by the effects of the presence, or absence, of an interviewer.

2. Explain what the statistics can and cannot be used for, and why

In its response to our compliance review, the Gambling Commission explains that it has produced guidance on how to use statistics from the GSGB and how it monitors the use of this guidance. For example, the Gambling Commission keeps a published log detailing instances where it has requested corrections to the use of its statistics. The Gambling Commission has also set up a dedicated email address (statistics@gamblingcommission.gov.uk) for users. Users can contact the Gambling Commission for advice on how to use and communicate the Gambling Commission’s statistics or if they want to report incidences of data misrepresentation.

Following the research by Sturgis et al (2025), the Gambling Commission updated its guidance to make clearer what the statistics can and cannot be used for and why. The updated guidance was sent to the GSGB Statistics User Group and discussed at a webinar in September 2025, prior to the publication of the annual report in October 2025.

Within the guidance, the Gambling Commission has explained exactly how GSGB estimates can and cannot be used, with example quotes for how estimates can be reported. These can be directly lifted by users and are a useful aid to support appropriate use of the statistics, especially as they have been updated for the release of the 2025 annual report in July 2026.

3. Ensure guidance on how to use the statistics is easy to find and tailored to different users

The GSGB guidance includes examples of how to report findings from the survey appropriately, to support different users. There are links to the guidance from the summary page of the annual report, as well as the GSGB landing page, the cover sheet within the data tables and the ‘user engagement’ section of the technical report.

Within the 2025 annual report, there is an ‘Interpretation of the data’ section on the first page, which discusses uncertainty and confidence intervals, but also advises users not to make comparisons with other surveys. Following feedback from OSR, the technical report, as well as Sturgis et al’s (2025) research, is now linked from the first page of the annual report, though the guidance is not.

OSR judgement

We consider this recommendation to be partially met.

It is good that the Gambling Commission communicates uncertainty by clearly referring to the statistics as estimates and prominently discussing margins of error and confidence intervals within the statistical release. The guidance on using statistics from the GSGB continues to provide clear information and up-to-date examples on how the GSGB statistics can and cannot be used. For completeness, and to make it as easy as possible for users to navigate to this important information, this guidance should be linked from within the statistical release and from the ‘data analysis and reporting’ section of the technical report.

However, there are biases that affect these statistics, and there is varying certainty as to the effects and direction of these biases. Users need to be aware of this key information to make informed decisions when using the GSGB. Being open about these issues will also help to foster trust.

The potential biases that affect GSGB statistics are complex and it can be challenging to communicate this information both comprehensively and succinctly. The Gambling Commission has included some valuable information on biases in the GSGB technical report and guidance. However, to ensure that users understand, and are aware of, key information about bias, the Gambling Commission should do more to improve both the content and the positioning of the current explanations.

In our view, the combination of the information within the technical report, the guidance, the statistical release, and the response to OSR’s compliance review does not sufficiently explain the bias associated with GSGB statistics and the implications of this. It is important that in these communications, the Gambling Commission gives consistent messages about bias and ensures that this key information is clear and easy to find.

It remains our view that the Gambling Commission should give further consideration to how bias is communicated clearly and prominently within the statistical release and how its messaging across different statistical publications is consistent.


Recommendation four

To support user understanding of the GSGB’s role in the broader gambling data landscape, the Gambling Commission should do more to investigate the coherence and comparability of GSGB statistics with other relevant data, such as from the Health Survey for England and the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey that will be published later in 2025, and communicate these findings to users.

Actions taken by the Gambling Commission

The Gambling Commission has communicated to users that the GSGB is one part of a much broader evidence base. For example, at the webinar to launch the GSGB Annual Report for 2025, the GSGB statistics team made it clear that the GSGB is part of the broader evidence base alongside other sources of information, such as Gambling Commission statistics and research, industry data and research, academic research, and open banking data.

The Gambling Commission has published Evidence Roadmaps, which are organised into themes, and set the direction for the Commission’s future research. Within these themes, it is again emphasised that the GSGB is a core dataset that sits within a much wider evidence base. The publication of the Evidence Roadmaps was accompanied by a blog explaining how these roadmaps are used to identify evidence gaps and set out the priority research themes needed to build a robust evidence base for gambling in Great Britain. An additional blog, published by the Gambling Commission in February 2026, explains how the Commission has aligned the timing of the publication of the GSGB estimates and its Industry Statistics to allow greater opportunity for investigating their comparability and coherence. Whilst carrying out our follow-up work on the GSGB compliance review, a concern was raised via our casework function regarding the coherence of the GSGB and the Industry Statistics produced by the Gambling Commission. As noted in the Gambling Commission’s blog, the two outputs collect different information over a slightly different time period. Therefore, whilst it is possible to look at the impact of trends, seasonality and events, as with all data triangulations, care needs to be taken to ensure like for like comparisons are being made.

Due to a lack of available data for the most recent health survey publications, it has not been possible for the Gambling Commission to investigate the coherence and comparability of GSGB statistics with the Health Survey for England (HSE) and the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey (APMS). However, the Gambling Commission has told us that the data are expected to be available by the end of 2026 and it will carry out this work then.

Although the Gambling Commission has not had the opportunity to examine the most recent HSE and APMS data, the GSGB analysis team at the National Centre for Social Research (NatCen) and the University of Glasgow were commissioned to produce research that investigated the coherence of the GSGB with the HSE. The resulting two studies investigated the coherence of elements of gambling behaviour, activities, Problem Gambling Severity Index scores, and wellbeing across the GSGB and the HSE, using publicly available data. The report, ‘GSGB: Different survey, same story?’, produced by Professor Heather Wardle, summarises this work and provides analysis comparing estimates from the HSE and the GSGB. Within this report, it is noted that past year participation estimates for specific activities (which includes in-person casino games and football pools) were similar for the HSE 2015 to 2018 and the GSGB 2023 to 2024. However, the past year participation estimates for these activities in HSE 2024 tended to be lower than the prior HSE estimates or the GSGB estimates. Professor Wardle recommends that in future, work is carried out to examine if the HSE results for 2024 ‘are indicative of a downward trend within this series or whether they are a statistical outlier’. The report concludes that while further work is needed to assess the extent to which different surveys produce comparable findings, ‘preliminary evidence from these reports suggests a strong level of consistency in the patterns and associations identified by the Gambling Survey for Great Britain (GSGB) and the Health Survey series’. This work provides insight into consistencies and differences between the GSGB and the HSE. However, the report recognises that this is preliminary evidence and further work is required. It is therefore our view that more comprehensive comparative work on the raw data from these surveys, such as the benchmarking suggested by Professor Sturgis, should still be completed.

The Gambling Commission has carried out other work to investigate the coherence and comparability of GSGB statistics with other relevant data. The Gambling Commission worked in collaboration with the Bingo Association to explore the differences between the Association’s own data on admissions to bingo clubs in the UK and estimates from the GSGB. The Gambling Commission published a report in April 2026 that explains the findings of this work and is now carrying out similar work concerning in-person casino games. Regarding in-person casino games, the Gambling Commission has added a new question to the GSGB to help understand the differences between GSGB estimates and industry administrative data. The Gambling Commission is also investigating differences between the GSGB and industry data for betting exchange and football pools, which have been brought to its attention by users.

The Gambling Commission has also examined the findings of gambling surveys in Ireland and Northern Ireland, and how Problem Gambling Severity Index scores from these surveys compare to the GSGB. The Gambling Commission provides a link to the Department for Communities’ 2024 Northern Ireland Gambling Prevalence Survey on its Continuous Improvement page and response to OSR page. The Commission also told us that it has engaged with colleagues in Ireland and Northern Ireland to discuss the methodological approach of their respective surveys, findings and stakeholder feedback.

OSR judgement

We consider this recommendation to be partially met.

The Gambling Commission has made considerable efforts to understand and communicate how the GSGB fits within the broader gambling data landscape. It has undertaken a significant amount of work to investigate the comparability and coherence of the GSGB with other surveys. In doing so, it has forged new relationships with stakeholders and carried out collaborative work with other organisations.

A key element of this recommendation was to investigate the coherence and comparability of GSGB statistics with the Health Survey for England and the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey. It was originally anticipated that the data to allow this analysis would be published in 2025, but it is yet to be made available. Therefore, the Gambling Commission has not had the opportunity to carry out this work and the reasons for this are outside of its control. However, given the importance of this work to understanding the coherence and comparability of these surveys and the potential reasons for any differences, this recommendation will remain open until this work has been completed. We also note that Sturgis et al (2025) highlighted the significance of this kind of benchmarking exercise in their conclusions.

The Gambling Commission has proactively communicated the findings of its investigations concerning comparability and coherence to users once the research is complete. However, the Commission can do more to communicate to users when this type of research is underway. For example, in order to assure users, the Gambling Commission should provide an update on its website regarding the work that is underway to investigate differences between GSGB estimates and industry data for in-person casino games, football pools and betting exchange. This is explored further under Recommendation six.

To further improve communication of the significant amount of work carried out on this topic, the Gambling Commission should also consider how to bring this information together in one place that is easy for users to find.


Recommendation five

To ensure that user needs are sought, documented and considered, the Gambling Commission should create and implement a GSGB user engagement strategy. This strategy should detail specific activities and how users will be involved at various stages of the survey’s future developments.

Actions taken by the Gambling Commission

The Gambling Commission has published a user engagement statement, which sets out its commitment to producing high-quality, timely and relevant statistics, and the importance of engagement in understanding users and their needs.

The statement outlines key user groups, such as the gambling industry, researchers, consumers, and charities. It also details how the Commission will continue to identify new users by inviting feedback and presenting at relevant conferences and events. The statement lists ways in which the Commission communicates with users, as well as channels for users to respond to the Commission, such as the dedicated GSGB email address for queries and feedback.

Since OSR’s review, the Commission has created a GSGB Statistics User Group. The user engagement statement includes information about this group and how users can join. The Gambling Commission told us how it is actively using this user group to ask for ideas and incorporate views in future developments of the GSGB. For example, the Commission has recently put out a call to the user group for ideas for new GSGB questions and has acted on previous user feedback through its work with the Bingo Association.

The Gambling Commission has regular contact with the user group through emails, webinars and user group meetings, though there is no set timetable of engagement and updates yet. 

OSR judgement

We consider this recommendation to be met.

The Gambling Commission has published a comprehensive statement that sets out how it proactively considers how to interact with users and understand their needs. The statement is also helpful in signposting users to how they can share their comments and feedback to help steer the GSGB’s development. The Commission’s new GSGB Statistics User Group is also a valuable mechanism to seek users’ views and facilitate regular communication.

To further enhance this communication with users, the Gambling Commission could consider implementing a more structured programme of engagement with its GSGB Statistics User Group, so that these users have assurance that upcoming events are taking place and they know when to expect updates.


Recommendation six

To build trust with users, the Gambling Commission should remain open to receiving challenge, provide feedback to users on their contributions and clearly communicate what can and cannot be addressed in the development of the GSGB statistics.

Actions taken by the Gambling Commission

1. The Gambling Commission should remain open to receiving challenge

Improving feedback mechanisms

As previously noted, the Gambling Commission has established a GSGB Statistics User Group to provide a forum for the exchange of views, ideas and information between users of the GSGB data and the Gambling Commission. The Gambling Commission has also developed a GSGB feedback form for users to provide ongoing feedback on the GSGB (for example on the technical report, statistical outputs, and guidance or data that are available through the Power BI dashboard). The Gambling Commission regularly reviews these forms and shares the ideas that have been suggested, and what can and cannot be addressed, via the user group meetings. The feedback form and the sign-up form for the user group are linked prominently on the landing page for the GSGB and are open to all.

Based on OSR feedback, the Gambling Commission has also established a dedicated email address (statistics@gamblingcommission.gov.uk) for the GSGB. Users can use this to contact the Gambling Commission about the survey, ask for advice on how to present the statistics, or report any incidences of misuse of GSGB data.

At the webinar to launch the GSGB Annual Report 2025, the GSGB statistics team presented the key findings but also invited feedback from users and explained how users can get in touch. The Gambling Commission subsequently provided written answers to users’ questions that it did not have time to answer during the webinar.

The Gambling Commission told us that within a new contract agreed with the National Centre for Social Research (NatCen) in January 2026 for delivery of the GSGB, it is stipulated that NatCen must create a ‘Data Analyst User Group’ which will gather feedback on GSGB data and host an annual meeting. The NatCen Data Analyst User Group is aimed at people who are doing analysis of the GSGB data. It will gather feedback from a more technical group of users, compared to the broader GSGB Statistics User Group.

Feedback from users on the Gambling Commission’s openness to receiving challenge

As previously discussed, the Gambling Commission has carried out work to investigate the coherence and comparability of GSGB estimates with industry data from the Bingo Association, and published its findings in a report. The Commission initiated this work after the Bingo Association identified differences between the two sources. However, some concerns have been raised via our casework function about the Gambling Commission’s openness to receiving challenge, specifically regarding comparisons of the GSGB with other data. For example, a small number of users shared an unpublished academic paper with us and the Gambling Commission, which identified potential over-reporting in the GSGB compared with gambling industry administrative data.

The concerns raised focused on the paper’s finding that the GSGB produces higher estimates of participation compared to industry data on in-person casino table games, football pools and betting exchanges. The users who contacted us were disappointed with how the Gambling Commission had responded to their concerns and did not feel that their feedback was addressed in a timely or constructive way. A small number of users commented that their engagement with the Gambling Commission had felt protracted and that their concerns were initially dismissed without proper scrutiny. Additionally, some users felt that the Gambling Commission should include warnings about this potential over-estimation of in-person casino games, betting exchanges and football pools in the statistical release.

The research shared with us and with the Gambling Commission demonstrates a significant difference between GSGB estimates and industry administrative data. However, the administrative data which is the basis of these complaints are not publicly available. The Betting and Gaming Council (BGC) provided us with the industry administrative data on casino visits. Like the GSGB, these data are subject to their own strengths and limitations, and it is for the Gambling Commission to investigate the differences between these different sources and explain the potential reasons why these may exist to users. We understand that the Gambling Commission and the BGC have met to discuss the differences between GSGB estimates and industry administrative data, and also the work that the Commission is carrying out to investigate these further. We welcome this approach to listen to, discuss and explore user concerns and we encourage the Gambling Commission to continue this approach to working with users.

Engaging with academic work

Regarding the unpublished academic paper that identified potential over-reporting in the GSGB compared with gambling industry administrative data, the Gambling Commission told us that engagement with academic work is handled on a case‑by‑case basis. The Gambling Commission further stated that it would not normally comment on academic work until it has been peer-reviewed. It also pointed out that access to underlying data is important to enable an assessment of claims and that resource issues will limit the attention that can be given to individual concerns.

2. Clearly communicating what can and cannot be addressed

The Gambling Commission stated in the webinar for the GSGB Annual Report 2025, and in the subsequent written questions and answers for attendees, that as the GSGB is a consumer survey it could be expected there would be some differences between self-reporting of using casino games in-person and industry administrative data. It was also acknowledged that this could be the case for football pools and betting exchanges. The Gambling Commission stated in the webinar’s written questions and answers that it has added a question to the GSGB about in-person casino games and is holding discussions about adding a question to the survey about using betting exchanges.

Adding new questions to the GSGB to investigate issues further

The Gambling Commission has added a new question to the GSGB on in-person casino games to aid its understanding of the differences between GSGB estimates and industry administrative data. This follows similar work the Gambling Commission conducted in collaboration with the Bingo Association to explore the differences between the Association’s own data on admissions to bingo clubs in the UK and estimates from the GSGB.

However, a small number of users have expressed concerns about the design of the additional question on in-person casino table games that has been added to the GSGB and how this question will perform. These users felt that their views had not been taken into consideration and felt unclear about how the question would provide appropriate insight into the issue. We understand that the Gambling Commission sought advice from NatCen on the new question and that timescales for question development were tight, which meant that decisions about adding a new question to the GSGB had to be made quickly.

OSR judgement

We consider this recommendation to be partially met.

The Gambling Commission has made good progress in establishing new, and improving existing, feedback mechanisms to allow a wider range of input from users on the GSGB and related publications.

However, the Gambling Commission should reconsider its original decision to not engage with issues raised by users until unpublished academic papers have been through the formal peer review process. In our view, regardless of how issues are brought to the attention of the Gambling Commission and who raises them, concerns about the statistics should be given proper scrutiny and investigated thoroughly. The Gambling Commission’s position meant that there was a delay in investigating users’ concerns, providing feedback on their contributions, and communicating what could be addressed. It is understandable that limited resources may restrict the timeliness of these investigations, but it is important that users feel listened to and receive feedback, in line with our original recommendation. We would not expect the Gambling Commission to peer review academic work, but where issues, discrepancies or concerns about the statistics are raised, we expect the Gambling Commission to welcome this input, proactively engage with users and the relevant organisation supplying the data, and set out what it can and cannot do to look into the issue further.

It is possible that there are valid reasons for the differences between survey data and industry data on in-person casino games, betting exchanges and the football pools, but it is important that these are understood better. Prompted by user challenge, we welcome the work that is underway concerning in-person casino games, the work that is now planned for football pools and betting exchanges, and the collaboration with industry representatives on this. We expect the Gambling Commission to proactively work with users in future to discuss the findings from this work, and potential future revisions to questions, as it is currently doing with the BGC. It is also valid that the Gambling Commission explores these issues further to gain a better understanding of differences before adding any specific caveats to the estimates, as requested by a small number of users.

To enhance transparency and assure its broader user base of how feedback and concerns are being addressed, we have previously suggested that the Gambling Commission signposts the development work that is in progress to users, and publishes updates on its website, for example on the ‘Continuous Improvements’ page. In due course, the Gambling Commission should also advise users of the findings of its investigations into the differences between survey data and industry data, and any implications for GSGB estimates.

Therefore, we have updated our original recommendation six to read as follows:

Recommendation 6: To build trust with users, the Gambling Commission should:

  • remain open to receiving challenge
  • provide feedback to users on their contributions
  • clearly communicate what can and cannot be addressed in the development of the GSGB statistics, and
  • publish updates on how user feedback and concerns are being addressed.

Recommendation seven

To benefit future statistics development and address diverse stakeholder needs, the Gambling Commission should broaden its stakeholder network and collaborate further with official statistics producers.

Actions taken by the Gambling Commission

Following our review, the Gambling Commission committed to reviewing and broadening its stakeholder network. As a result, the Gambling Commission has taken several actions to expand its stakeholder network. For example, it has:

  • joined the Statutory Levy Data working group, which brings together colleagues from across the Commission, the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS), UK Research and Innovation (UKRI), public health bodies and academia
  • onboarded a Policy Fellow from UKRI within the Gambling Commission to carry out further research into gambling behaviours. The Policy Fellow is contributing to a number of projects, including comparing GSGB to other data sources, exploring how binge gambling relates to other gambling behaviours and gambling harms, as well as leading a training programme to upskill the Gambling Commission statistics team in the use of R programming for statistical analysis. The Commission has also established links with a network of other Policy Fellows working on gambling research outside of the Commission, such as in DCMS and the Department of Health and Social Care
  • established links with the research teams at Ofcom and the Money and Pensions Service, and implemented regular meetings
  • hosted the Gambling Commission’s 2026 Evidence Conference, which drew around 150 attendees. The Gambling Commission also attended the Current Advances in Gambling Research conference in Helsinki, and participated in the inaugural meeting of the UKRI Gambling Harms Research UK network
  • contributed to two international working groups (the Gambling Regulators European Forum and the International Association of Gaming Regulators).

In our previous review, we noted that whilst there had been some engagement with stakeholders in Wales and Scotland, this could be broader and should be addressed in future work. The Gambling Commission has been liaising with Welsh Government and Public Health Wales (PHW) via the Statutory Levy Data working group. PHW is planning to boost the GSGB sample size to be able to carry out further analysis on estimates for Wales. This work is ongoing, and the Gambling Commission has facilitated the commissioning of NatCen to undertake the same work for Scotland by Public Health Scotland.

In its response to OSR’s review, the Gambling Commission explains how it added colleagues in Scottish and Welsh Government to its pre-release access list for the 2023 annual report, following feedback that they would like to be included. The Gambling Commission confirmed that this decision was reviewed with DCMS’s Head of Profession for Statistics in line with pre-release access principles and has now published its pre-release access arrangements.

OSR judgement

We consider this recommendation to be met.

The Gambling Commission has expanded its stakeholder network through engaging with relevant industry bodies and operators, and other government and research institutions. It has also established links with international organisations. It is particularly encouraging to see that some of these relationships have resulted in further collaboration and commissioned work.


Recommendation eight

To improve the effectiveness of its communication, the Gambling Commission should publish a communication strategy detailing how it will approach sharing GSGB updates with users and stakeholders, taking user preferences into account where possible.

Actions taken by the Gambling Commission

The Gambling Commission has now published a communications plan, which sets out the role of the GSGB as part of a wider evidence base that helps to provide a comprehensive picture of gambling in Great Britain. The Gambling Commission’s communications plan states the key objectives, audiences, messages and communications channels that will shape the Gambling Commission’s approach to engaging with users. The plan is also aligned with part of the Gambling Commission’s strategic focus for 2024 to 2027 concerning the use of data and analytics to make gambling regulation more effective.

The Gambling Commission now also includes information about the GSGB in its fortnightly e-bulletin, which provides updates on its work. The e-bulletin that was distributed just after the publication of the GSGB Annual Report 2025 linked to both the report and a blog post that summarised the key findings from the release, referred to the interactive dashboard, linked to the technical report, and highlighted updates to the guidance.

OSR judgement

We consider this recommendation to be met.

The communications plan clearly sets out the Gambling Commission’s strategic approach to GSGB communications and the e-bulletin ensures that users are informed of relevant publications in a frequent, timely and transparent way.

For greater transparency and accessibility, the Commission could publish the communications plan as a standalone document rather than as an appendix to its response to OSR’s review. It could also link to its user engagement statement, which provides greater detail about how the Gambling Commission interacts with users, who it interacts with, and how users can provide feedback.


Recommendation nine

To enhance the usability and accessibility of GSGB outputs, the Gambling Commission should consider how it can align further development of these statistics, including the detail that is provided and how it is presented, with user needs.

Actions taken by the Gambling Commission

In response to this recommendation, the Gambling Commission made changes to the usability and accessibility of its GSGB outputs, starting with the GSGB Annual Report 2024 (published in October 2025). The Gambling Commission incorporated hyperlinks from the contents page in its published data tables to the relevant table of data and also added more content to the Power BI dashboard. As part of the development of the dashboard, the Commission also consulted the GSGB Statistics User Group and incorporated its feedback.

The Gambling Commission has also published GSGB data to the UK Data Service.

On its ‘GSGB review and response to OSR’ page, the Gambling Commission also committed to investigating adding a DOI (Digital Object Identifier) to its reports to enable permanent and reliable accessibility even if their location (URL) changes.

OSR judgement

We consider this recommendation to be met.

The Gambling Commission has made improvements to how users navigate GSGB data and has increased the volume of available data. The Commission has enhanced the accessibility of GSGB data by publishing the dataset to the UK Data Service to help facilitate further analysis. The Gambling Commission has investigated adding DOIs to its report but has concluded that due to the cost and the way that its reports are published on its website, this will not be feasible. To ensure transparency about its conclusions, the Gambling Commission should update its ‘GSGB review and response to OSR’ page with the most up-to-date information.


Additional findings – interpretation of the research by Sturgis et al (2025) and subsequent updates to guidance

In addition to evidence that is directly linked to our recommendations, a related issue was raised via our casework function. This concerns how the Gambling Commission supports appropriate interpretation and use of GSGB statistics via the guidance that it provides to users. Specifically, a small number of users brought to our attention their concerns about the Gambling Commission’s interpretation of the research by Sturgis et al (2025) and the decisions that the Gambling Commission has made as a result, particularly regarding its GSGB guidance.

Extrapolation of findings from the research by Sturgis et al (2025) to the GSGB

A small number of users raised concerns that the mode of interview administration in the research by Sturgis et al (2025) was not the same as that used in health surveys that collect information about gambling behaviour, such as the Health Survey for England (HSE). In the experiment carried out by Sturgis et al (2025), interviews were administered via telephone whereas the HSE uses face-to-face administration. Some users stated that on this basis comparisons should not be made between the experimental study and surveys such as the HSE. Sturgis et al (2025) state in their report that some care is required in extrapolating the effect observed in their research to in-person interviews but say ‘we can be confident in concluding that a good part of the difference that we observe between online and in-person interview surveys in estimates of gambling behaviour is due to downward biases from interviewer administration’.

It is our understanding that the purpose of the research was to test the variable of interviewer presence and that telephone interviewing was used given the prohibitive cost of in-person interviewing. Therefore, this does not perfectly replicate the mode that is used in other surveys. However, in our view, it is possible to infer the effect of interviewer presence, whilst noting the limitations of extrapolating from one mode to another, such as understanding the exact magnitude of the effect.

The Gambling Commission’s increased confidence in the GSGB following the findings from Sturgis et al (2025)

Following the publication of research by Sturgis et al (2025), the Gambling Commission has reported that it has increased confidence in the quality of the estimates from the GSGB. For example, the GSGB guidance states that ‘as a result of the research we can have more confidence in the accuracy of the estimates produced by the GSGB’. A Gambling Commission news story published in 2025 referred to its ‘strengthened confidence in the robustness of GSGB estimates’ as a result of the research. For both examples, there is no further explanation of exactly how the research findings increase confidence in all GSGB estimates.

Some of the concerns raised with OSR questioned how the Gambling Commission had interpreted the findings of Sturgis et al (2025) and specifically how it could have increased confidence following the study. In our view, it is reasonable to infer from the research that interviewer presence may lead to underestimation of gambling harm. Therefore, as self-completion surveys are not subject to the effects of interviewer presence, it is also reasonable to infer that self-completion surveys produce more accurate estimates of gambling harm compared to interviewer-administered surveys. However, in our view, this conclusion must be accompanied by appropriate caveats. For example, the study also found that mentioning gambling explicitly in the survey invitation, as is done for the GSGB, led to an increase in reported gambling participation. This suggests that the GSGB attracts gamblers, even if it is not known how this bias affects the accuracy of the estimates. As previously noted, this is a bias that should be acknowledged within the statistical release.

The Gambling Commission should also ensure that the language it is using to describe the research by Sturgis et al (2025) is precise. For example, the Gambling Commission states on its ‘Implementing the recommendations from Professor Sturgis’ page that ‘These findings [Sturgis et al’s] suggest that responses to PGSI [Problem Gambling Severity Index] questions may be suppressed in interviewer-led surveys, due to social desirability bias. In contrast, the GSGB’s self-completion methodology may encourage more honest reporting of gambling behaviours.’ In our view, it is not possible to determine from the research that the GSGB encourages more ‘honest’ reporting. This language is not used in the report produced by Sturgis et al (2025). Using more precise language, for example to say that the GSGB’s use of a self-completion methodology may mean that respondents are less likely to give socially desirable responses, will better support users’ understanding of the research and its implications.

Within the GSGB guidance, the Gambling Commission implies that the research by Sturgis et al (2025) indicates that the GSGB is more accurate. The Gambling Commission states that ‘the GSGB’s self-completion methodology largely avoids this measurement bias and encourages more accurate reporting of gambling behaviours’. In our view, it is fair to infer that estimates of gambling harm from the GSGB may be more accurate than interviewer-administered surveys as the GSGB is not subject to the same social desirability bias. However, the Gambling Commission does not explain what other reporting of gambling behaviours it is comparing the GSGB to and does not explain the broader context (that the GSGB is subject to other bias that may affect the outputs of the survey).

Removal of guidance not to gross up estimates to population level

Prior to October 2025, in the GSGB guidance the Gambling Commission advised that Problem Gambling Severity Index estimates should not be grossed up to whole numbers in the population, whilst it was waiting for the findings of experimental research (Sturgis et al, 2025). The Gambling Commission now states that as a result of the research by Sturgis et al (2025), it has ‘more confidence in the accuracy of the estimates produced by the GSGB’ and that because of this, it updated GSGB guidance in October 2025 ‘to remove some of the caution we previously advised’. The instruction to not gross up estimates of gambling harm to whole numbers in the population is no longer in place. Some of the concerns that have been raised via our casework function relate to this decision to amend this part of the guidance. It is clear that a small number of users do not understand how the research by Sturgis et al (2025) has influenced the Gambling Commission’s decision making in this instance.

We agree that the decision to remove this caveat does not directly follow on from the research findings, as the research did not specifically investigate or advise about this part of the guidance. However, that does not mean that the Gambling Commission’s decision was wrong. In our view, it is reasonable to allow the grossing up of estimates of gambling harm to whole numbers in the population, provided that these are clearly described as estimates by users, in line with the Gambling Commission’s guidance. As the producer of these statistics, it is for the Gambling Commission to advise users on the most appropriate use. It is reasonable for producers to also consider user need in making these decisions. A small number of users raised concerns with us that, in making this decision, the Gambling Commission had misrepresented the purpose of the study and acted under the influence of external stakeholders. We have not seen any evidence of an intention to deliberately mislead, but we do consider that the Gambling Commission can do more to explain the research, how it has interpreted the findings, and how these have informed decisions it has taken as a result.

The Gambling Commission’s explanation of the research by Sturgis et al (2025)

The issues and concerns raised to us also indicated that a small number of users do not understand the purpose of the research, what it set out to investigate (and what it did not investigate), and what its findings mean. For example, that the research was not intended to investigate the accuracy of the GSGB but to examine the underlying causes of the differences between online self-completion surveys and face-to-face surveys examining gambling behaviours.

Sturgis et al’s (2025) research, ‘Three experiments on the causes of differences in estimates of gambling and gambling impacts in general population surveys’, is published in full, and the Gambling Commission provides links to this research in several locations on its website. The Gambling Commission also hosted webinars with Professor Sturgis to explain the research to users. Whilst the Gambling Commission does provide information about Sturgis et al’s (2025) work within the technical report and the guidance, it should do more to explain the research in its own words, and in one place. This will help users to understand the research and the Gambling Commission’s interpretation of it, how this interpretation has been applied to the GSGB, the action the Gambling Commission has taken as a result, and the greater confidence that the Gambling Commission now has in the GSGB. We have therefore identified the following additional recommendation for the Gambling Commission to address.

Recommendation 10: To improve user understanding of the actions that the Gambling Commission has taken as a result of the findings from the research by Sturgis et al (2025), the Gambling Commission should:

  • explain the purpose, findings, strengths, and limitations of the research in an accessible way
  • explain in more detail how it has interpreted these findings, how they have influenced its confidence in the GSGB, and the subsequent decisions that have been taken as a result
  • revisit the wording of some of the GSGB’s supporting materials to ensure that more precise wording is used when interpreting the findings by Sturgis et al (2025).